Is Borreby the Most Common Racial Type in Germany?

[Prodigal Son]

TSo it is a stereotypical type, and perhaps those who are of that Phenotype are seen as quintessential Germans by the common observer.

I don't know where you get your data from. According to Coon, Borreby is the most common type in Germany.

[Loki]

I don't know where you get your data from. According to Coon, Borreby is the most common type in Germany.

A few minutes ago you said Coon's theories should be binned as they are wrong.... lol.

Besides I think most of us (except you, apparently) know that Borreby is only common in northern Germany. Also, cite your source for this Coon quote, please. When you are done, I will quote Coon on Ladogans

[Polak]

I think Coon said that Falid was the most common type in Germany. And it is.

Pure Borrebys, according to Coon, were only found on some islands in the Baltic.

[Allenson]

I think Coon said that Falid was the most common type in Germany. And it is.

Pure Borrebys, according to Coon, were only found on some islands in the Baltic.

I'll have to look but I seem to remember that Coon didn't really recognize the Falid type. I might be worng here but I don't think it was in his scheme. He might have paid a little 'lip service' to it in his photo section under "Nordics altered by NW European UP Mixture".

Specifically the middle two fellows:

http://www.fikas.no/~sprocket/snpa/index2.htm

I'm not convinced that it is a Nord x UP though....

[Vojvoda]

I'll have to look but I seem to remember that Coon didn't really recognize the Falid type. I might be worng here but I don't think it was in his scheme. He might have paid a little 'lip service' to it in his photo section under "Nordics altered by NW European UP Mixture".

Specifically the middle two fellows:

http://www.fikas.no/~sprocket/snpa/index2.htm

I'm not convinced that it is a Nord x UP though....

Off topic, excuse me

I wonder why the website dalonord posted doesn't contain Coon's "Nordics of Danubian predominance" found on the "legion europa" website?

http://www.legioneuropa.org/Racediv/...Papers/p28.htm

[Loki]

Off topic, excuse me

I wonder why the website dalonord posted doesn't contain Coon's "Nordics of Danubian predominance" found on the "legion europa" website?

Perhaps because it is not the Bible, and thus cannot be expected to contain everything about the Nordish races. They (Dagfinn, Jarle & Vegard) usually post stuff to the site as they get the time. Not even the entire Races of Europe has been posted as yet. I hardly think it is any sort of conspiracy, as some would suggest.

[Vojvoda]

Perhaps because it is not the Bible, and thus cannot be expected to contain everything about the Nordish races. They (Dagfinn, Jarle & Vegard) usually post stuff to the site as they get the time. Not even the entire Races of Europe has been posted as yet. I hardly think it is any sort of conspiracy, as some would suggest.

I don't think it's a conspiracy either, I mean they have "Neo-Danubians" so why not have "Danubian Nordids" as well?

[Prodigal Son]

A few minutes ago you said Coon's theories should be binned as they are wrong.... lol.

When and where did I say that?

Besides I think most of us (except you, apparently) know that Borreby is only common in northern Germany. Also, cite your source for this Coon quote, please. When you are done, I will quote Coon on Ladogans

Coon's ideas about so-called Ladogans have been refuted by 50 years of solid anthropological work; I am not so sure about his idead regarding Borrebies. One thing I do know for a fact is that Nordics do not predominate in Germany. There is a trend among Nordicists here to "pinkwash", or perhaps even to "dolio-wash" Germany, painting it as an area that is racially indistinguishable from Scandinavia. This whole notion, is of course utterly ridiculous. Germans are a predominantly UP population.

[Loki]

When and where did I say that?

Here:

http://www.forums.skadi.net/showthre...?t=3710&page=3

One thing I do know for a fact is that Nordics do not predominate in Germany. There is a trend among Nordicists here to "pinkwash", or perhaps even to "dolio-wash" Germany, painting it as an area that is racially indistinguishable from Scandinavia. This whole notion, is of course utterly ridiculous. Germans are a predominantly UP population.

Nobody here, as far as I can remember, said that Germany was indistiguishable from Scandinavia. Germany's most important element is the Falish type, whereas the Gothic and Tronder types are important and typical of Sweden and Norway (other types exist there too).

So you are attacking views which have never been uttered here, in effect

However, on the other hand you are also guilty of oversimplifying Germany's racial history and composition. And you might be guilty of "dolio-washing" or "pink-washing" Russian and other Slavic populations yourself

[Prodigal Son]

Here:

http://www.forums.skadi.net/showthre...?t=3710&page=3

"snub-nosed Ladogan fantasies" is an insult now? I think you're overly sensetive

Germany's most important element is the Falish type

What's your source for this claim?

So you are attacking views which have never been uttered here, in effect

Not so. I've seen plenty of people here make the claim that Germany is predominanly Nordic, but I am not going to go "thread-hunting" right now.

However, on the other hand you are also guilty of oversimplifying Germany's racial history and composition.

I don't really think saying that Germans are predominantly of UP stock is an oversimplification.

And you might be guilty of "dolio-washing" or "pink-washing" Russian and other Slavic populations yourself

No, I am just setting the record straight. Many people here seem to think that Russians look like Lapps or Samoyeds.