Arndt's railing against the French was opposed in his time by the traitors among his own people and not few spoke of the benefits that French rule brought to them, and supposedly to the German people as a whole. And still, it was not the French counterculture and their revolt against the French monarchy that led him to disapprove of the attempt to destroy his people. The simple reason is that he was a German nationalist and he could not allow a situation where a foreign people dictates the future of his own:
"Wenn ich sage, ich hasse den französischen Leichtsinn, ich verschmähe die französische Zierlichkeit, mir missfällt die französische Geschwätzigkeit und Flatterhaftigkeit, so spreche ich vielleicht einen Mangel aus, aber einen Mangel, der mir mit meinem ganzen Volke gemein ist. Ebenso kann ich sagen: Ich hasse den englischen Übermut, die englische Sprödigkeit, die englische Abgeschlossenheit. Diese gehassten und verachteten und getadelten Eigenschaften sind an sich noch keine Laster, sie hängen bei den Völkern, die sie tragen, vielleicht mit großen Tugenden zusammen, die mir und meinem Volke fehlen. Darum lasst uns die Franzosen nur recht frisch hassen, lasst uns unsre Franzosen, die Entehrer und Verwüster unserer Kraft und Unschuld, nur noch frischer hassen, wo wir fühlen, dass sie unsere Tugend und Stärke verweichlichen und entnerven."
The American restructuring of Germany did not simply rehash the development of the West up until the early modern state, it also reintroduced more recent developments that are now considered as defining for the West, such as representative democracy and human rights, which we had discarded again as part of a larger project to reform our society. This was rightly perceived by others as a break with Western civilization.
The very idea of merging a pre-existing nation with the modern state to form a nation state is already a divergence from the normative development in Western Europe, where state authority issued a common legal status and thereby defined its people. Furthermore, it is at odds with the fundamental logic of Westianity, where faith and obedience alone is the requirement for membership and those who primarily identify with their ancestral ties are savages, ethnics and also nationes.
So, the task ahead for the German nation is to once again bring about the transformation of our society. Ideally, this would not be a collapse rather than a controlled purification from worthless Western paradigms, but we should be prepared for the possibility that Western control over us persists too long and the annihilative fantasies of our enemies are at least partially fulfilled.
Bookmarks