Results 1 to 2 of 2

Thread: War Films: the Great Escape from the Truth

  1. #1
    Senior Member Guntwachar's Avatar
    Join Date
    Mar 2008
    Last Online
    Monday, January 31st, 2011 @ 10:40 PM
    Status
    Available
    Ethnicity
    Dutch
    Ancestry
    Netherlands, Germany, Sweden, Denmark, England, Scotland & Normandy
    Country
    Netherlands Netherlands
    State
    South Holland South Holland
    Gender
    Age
    29
    Family
    In a steady relationship
    Occupation
    Musician
    Politics
    Free-Thinker & Anti-Monarchist
    Religion
    Heiden
    Posts
    681
    Thanks Thanks Given 
    0
    Thanks Thanks Received 
    0
    Thanked in
    0 Posts

    War Films: the Great Escape from the Truth

    The reality of Stalag Luft III was far grimmer than the romanticised derring-do that became typical of postwar movies

    This is a true story,” proclaims the title card at the opening of The Great Escape, perhaps the most popular Second World War film ever made.

    “Although the characters are composites of real men, and time and place have been compressed, every detail of the escape is the way it really happened.” That claim was disputed by, among others, Squadron Leader Eric Dowling, one of the last surviving participants in the escape plan, who died this week at the age of 92. “Digger” Dowling, who helped to construct the only tunnel that was not discovered by the Germans, always insisted that the 1963 film depicting the breakout from Stalag Luft III in 1944 was partly fantasy.

    The scene in which the American officer played by Steve McQueen leaps the barbed wire on a stolen motorbike was “rubbish”, said Mr Dowling. No American servicemen took part in the final escape, as all had been moved to another compound before the prisoners broke out. McQueen makes his great leap on a Triumph 650, which was not even built until 1963.

    For Mr Dowling, the horrible reality of tunnelling - the fear, claustrophobia and exhaustion - was missing from the film. “He felt it turned into something that was completely untrue,” according to Mr Dowling's son. “For someone who was actually there, that was upsetting.”

    The Great Escape is a great film, but unreliable history. It is a cracking story, but the truth of what happened, as so often, is more complex and demanding than the fiction larded over it.

    The film offers a plot as straight as McQueen's jawline, and as stiff as Richard Attenborough's upper lip, but for many of the PoWs the escape from Stalag Luft III was a tragedy, culminating in a shocking Nazi war crime. Just three men escaped; 50 were executed by the Gestapo in defiance of the Geneva Convention. Seven of Mr Dowling's friends were murdered. “What to many people was an epic wartime film was to him a serious event.” Many old soldiers from that war suffered from seeing their memories and experiences distilled and simplified through the camera lens, rendered as mere entertainment, distorted by the demands of patriotic propaganda and politics.

    The austerity of the 1950s and the cultural clashes of the 1960s encouraged film-makers to look back with one-dimensional nostalgia on the war, as a time of simple moral verities, when Allied Good triumphed over Axis Evil and every man in British uniform was a hero.

    But war is never as black and white as the black-and-white films made it seem. Armed conflict is usually a grim and grey area. It exposes ordinary people to extraordinary moral pressure. A few respond with bravery and conviction, a few with cowardice and compromise, but most with something in between. In the PoW camps, so often portrayed as jolly mini-wars where whistling, bristling Tally Ho-types prepared dashing escapes, there were also those who collaborated, or crumbled under the horror.

    Postwar film had little room for nuance, particularly Hollywood's movies, which followed an agenda that still skews history today: to the victor, the reels. Churchill was enraged in 1945 when Objective, Burma!, starring Errol Flynn, depicted a raid by British and Commonwealth troops as an American triumph. Fifty-five years later, in U-571, the British coup in capturing the Enigma machine from a German U-boat was baldly depicted as the work of American submariners.

    Many veterans chose not to discuss their experiences. Some considered it poor form to boast of wartime derring-do. Today, when the merest hint of courage is rewarded by instant fame, their reticence seems astonishing, and deeply moving.

    At the same time there were others who capitalised and exaggerated their battlefield stories, usually with an eye to Hollywood. Many turned to ghost writers, and a slew of books appeared in the 1950s which were at best only partially accurate, and at worst thoroughly misleading and sensational.

    Winnowing out the truth from invention was not only difficult, but unwelcome. The wartime generation knew that that the reality of war was cold, hunger, fear, exhaustion and often mind-crushing boredom. The simplified, heroic version was much more palatable, but as a result men like Mr Dowling were forced to stand by as their own pasts were expropriated and idealised into something they could not recognise.

    In recent years the release of official documents has enabled historians to reassess and, to some extent, rewrite wartime stories with a more balanced eye. The Imperial War Museum has gathered a rich trove of recordings, in which the participants speak for themselves. The success of the Forgotten Voices series is further proof of a desire to hear history clearly, unfiltered by the demands of entertainment or politics.

    Films such as Oliver Hirschbiegel's Downfall and Paul Verhoeven's Black Book have also sought to offer a more subtle interpretation of war, reflecting the dilemmas of individual choice and experience rather than some Manichaean struggle between Good and Evil.

    The Great Escape deserves a remake. The tale on which it is based was a formidable feat of organisation, and a doomed act of collective resistance. But the film is now a period piece, reflecting the way that postwar society wanted to view the past.

    “Digger” Dowling played only a small part in the real escape. He was not among the 250 prisoners selected to break out. His role was restricted to preparing forged documents, and digging for days in the cold, damp Polish earth - an experience of such spectacular nastiness that Dowling never forgot it.

    That act of remembrance required another sort of bravery, and determined resistance of a different sort. While the film offered a popular version of reality, with jaunty American heroes and a chirpy script, Dowling, like many old soldiers, quietly guarded and preserved his own memories, knowing that the truth is both stranger than fiction, and much more interesting.



    Source: http://www.timesonline.co.uk/tol/com...cle4481367.ece
    If christ is the answer then what is the question?

  2. #2
    Senior Member
    Join Date
    Jul 2018
    Last Online
    39 Minutes Ago @ 02:56 PM
    Ethnicity
    Celto-Germanic
    Ancestry
    Irish, Scottish
    Country
    United Kingdom United Kingdom
    Location
    North Ireland
    Gender
    Family
    Married
    Politics
    National Socialist
    Religion
    Ethnic Catholic
    Posts
    692
    Thanks Thanks Given 
    735
    Thanks Thanks Received 
    882
    Thanked in
    465 Posts

    'Great Escape' veteran who called film 'absolute rubbish' dies aged 101


    Postwar film had little room for nuance, particularly Hollywood's movies, which followed an agenda that still skews history today: to the victor, the reels.

    Today, when the merest hint of courage is rewarded by instant fame, their reticence seems astonishing, and deeply moving.

    At the same time there were others who capitalised and exaggerated their battlefield stories, usually with an eye to Hollywood. Many turned to ghost writers, and a slew of books appeared in the 1950s which were at best only partially accurate, and at worst thoroughly misleading and sensational.

    Winnowing out the truth from invention was not only difficult, but unwelcome. The wartime generation knew that that the reality of war was cold, hunger, fear, exhaustion and often mind-crushing boredom. The simplified, heroic version was much more palatable, but as a result men like Mr Dowling were forced to stand by as their own pasts were expropriated and idealised into something they could not recognise.

    Posted by Guntwachar.






    The former RAF navigator never managed to escape the camp in events later portrayed in the Steve McQueen film.




    WORLD WAR TWO veteran Jack Lyon, one of the last veterans of the famous ‘Great Escape’, has died at the age of 101. The former RAF navigator passed away at his home in Bexhill-on-Sea on Friday, according to the BBC.

    Lyon was the lookout during the breakout attempt from the Stalag Luft III POW camp in 1944, which was later made into a film starring Steve McQueen in 1963.

    However, the escape tunnel was uncovered before Lyon had a chance to escape the camp himself, which he said was likely to have saved his life.

    50 of the 76 prisoners who escaped from the camp were executed on the orders of Adolf Hitler.
    “Had I got out, I probably wouldn’t be talking to you because my chances of getting home were virtually nil. I was under no illusions about that,” Lyon told the BBC on his 100th birthday in 2017.

    He also described the Hollywood portrayal of events as “absolute rubbish”, saying “not one American” took part in the escape and that the motorbike used by Steve McQueen in the film “never existed”.

    RAFBF chief executive Air Vice Marshal David Murray also told BBC that Lyon “belonged to a generation of servicemen” that were sadly being lost as time went on. “His legacy and those of his brave comrades who planned and took part in the audacious Great Escape breakout, are the freedoms we enjoy today,” Murray said.

    “To truly pay tribute to his memory and all this who have gone before him, we must never forget.”


    'Great Escape' veteran who called film 'absolute rubbish' dies aged 101 12 Mar 2019.


    Without the film, the shooting of the escapees would never have been noticed and remembered among the millions of deaths in WW II.

    All WW II films are pure propaganda.

Similar Threads

  1. German ‘Insult’ To Great Escape Heroes
    By SaxonPagan in forum The German Countries
    Replies: 9
    Last Post: Thursday, April 21st, 2011, 05:36 PM
  2. Great Resource for Old German Films.
    By Ralf in forum Film, TV, & Performing Arts
    Replies: 0
    Last Post: Sunday, April 10th, 2011, 05:52 PM
  3. Adrian Hamilton: 'A great escape? Dunkirk was actually a humiliation for British forces'
    By SaxonPagan in forum Modern Age & Contemporary History
    Replies: 1
    Last Post: Saturday, May 22nd, 2010, 01:42 AM
  4. 'Digger' Dowling, the Modest War Hero Who Inspired - but Hated - The Great Escape
    By BeornWulfWer in forum Film, TV, & Performing Arts
    Replies: 0
    Last Post: Thursday, August 7th, 2008, 08:30 PM
  5. Great site with tons of info on B-Films
    By RoyBatty in forum Film, TV, & Performing Arts
    Replies: 2
    Last Post: Thursday, May 12th, 2005, 10:56 PM

Bookmarks

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •